21st ANNUAL MULTICHANNEL MERCHANT AWARDS
Syndicated/Co-op
GOLD: PRINT CHANNEL
Catalyst Communication | David's World Cycle, 2005 Cycling Guide
Picturesque
mountains rising above a line of fir trees are the backdrop for the
front cover of the David's World Cycle 2005 Cycling Guide catalog.
Completing the picture are two cyclists riding in the foreground, while
below the logo reads the tagline: “It's All About The Experience.” At
the bottom of the page, below the cyclists, another tagline reads:
“Wherever You Ride, We Have The Bike For You.” All of which sums up the
catalog, and the company, perfectly.
Why it won a Gold Award
This
catalog draws in both avid cyclists and novices and never lets go.
Merchandise coupons, advertisements for weeklong bike excursions, and
cycling tips are among the elements that set this catalog apart. One
sidebar, for example, discusses the pros and cons of aluminum, steel,
titanium, and carbon fiber bike frames. Other topics covered in the tip
sections include how to select a bike for a child and how to “pedal
like the pros.”
“Excellent
usage of cycling information to make David's World Cycle a trusted
expert,” a judge declared. “Interesting use of personalized coupons and
even a letter to a senator recommending approval of bike-related
legislation. All of the additional information makes the catalog useful
as a cycling equipment guide and makes the company come across as a
source for serious cyclists.”
A
serious cycling catalog wouldn't be complete without pictures of and
references to seven-time Tour de France champion Lance Armstrong.
“Saddle up with the #1 Name in Bikes” a headline on page 3 says,
accompanied by a picture of Armstrong. The subhead reads: “Trek road
bikes: Lance-level performance for everyone.” The catalog also includes
photos of three-time Tour de France winner Greg LeMond. The references
to these cycling celebrities solidify the catalog's own credibility.
“There's
lots of information” in the book, noted a panelist, “but it's easy to
read and follow, thanks in part to the placement of the
product-specific benefits near images.” Silhouettes of bicycles, for
instance, are accompanied by captionlike call-outs such as “Shorter
crankarms for better acceleration” and “Stable handling and more
upright position for comfort and control.”
In
summation, one judge stated: “Copy excellence, category ownership,
product shots that are enticing — everything about this catalog leaves
you wanting to buy.”
Idea to steal
On
the inside front cover, next to a brief president's letter and a few
paragraphs detailing the benefits of buying from David's, is a column
entitled “Ask David's World Cycle: Answers to common service
questions.” There's no “sell” in the answers — other than the soft sell
of David's expertise. — JT
Director/creative director: Leslie Bohm
Designers: Jason Poole, Scott Kronberg, Robb Deeter
Marketing director: Vanessa Curry
Print/production director: Theresa Regnier
Operations director: Gregg Thayer
Copywriter: Lee McCormack
Photography: Trek
Printer: Royle Printing
List manager: Kevin Stein
List broker: Jim Hall, Chilcutt
Cover paper: 80 lb., Influence gloss book
Text paper: 70 lb., Influence gloss book
Trim size: 9" × 10-7/8"
Number of pages: 28
SILVER: PRINT CHANNEL
Catalyst Communication | Black Creek Outfitters, Outdoor Guide, Fall/Winter 2005
As
it says on the catalog's inside front cover, Black Creek Outfitters is
“the First Coast's premier outdoor store.” The bottom of the short
greeting is signed by the owners, the Butler family — Helen, Joe Jr.,
and Joe Sr. This homey flavor runs throughout the catalog.
Why it won a Silver Award
Besides
the family greeting, the inside cover touches on topics such as the
staff's knowledge of kayaking, hiking, and other outdoor activities;
guaranteed special ordering (at no extra cost) of out-of-stock items;
and a company history.
It also mentions the company's pledge of 1% of
net sales to the Red Cross for hurricane relief and has snapshots of
grinning staffers. “It's a great page two,” enthused a judge.
The
panelists thought that the mix of product copy and editorial features
(tips on staying warm when engaging in winter sports, “Fun Foot Facts,”
a listing of river conservation organizations, even a recipe for spicy
hot chocolate) was solid as well. “Good use of supplemental information
to a backpacking customer that is interested,” said one judge. “Great
use of fun facts,” added another member of the panel.
Why it didn't win a Gold Award
“The
cover design is too institutional for this market,” contended a judge.
Said another: “The front cover is average at best, and there's no
product featured on the back cover.”
The
back cover featured virtually the only mention of Black Creek
Outfitters' phone number and URL. Even though the catalog's primary
purpose is to drive retail traffic, the judges felt that more
cross-referencing of the Website in particular was in order, especially
as the site includes such features as equipment checklists and events
listings. — JT
Director/creative director: Leslie Bohm
Designers: Kristal Boni, Diane French
Print/production director: Theresa Regnier
Operations director: Gregg Thayer
Copywriter: Diane French
Photography: PatitucciPhoto, Jef Maion at Nomad's Land, JupiterImages
Printer: Times Printing
List manager: Vanessa Curry
List broker: Jim Hall, Chilcutt
Cover paper: 80 lb., Influence #2
Text paper: 70 lb., Influence #2
Trim size: 9-1/4" × 9-1/5"
Number of pages: 20
SILVER: WEB CHANNEL
Tessco | www.tessco.com
If
you're in the market for wireless products and solutions, the Website
of Tessco Technologies is a good place to start. The home page of the
Silver Award-winning site includes such categories as Network
Infrastructure Equipment, Mobile Devices & Accessories, and
Installation, Test, Equipment & Supplies, all of which are no doubt
valuable to shoppers of wireless equipment.
Why it won a Silver Award
You
may have to be a wireless technology guru to truly appreciate the
Tessco site. For instance, if you need mobile antennas, transmission
lines and cables, or calibration tools, you should be able to find them
here. The navigation labels are technical, noted one judge, but “they
probably make sense to Tessco's customers.”
Same
thing with the copy, which “contains bullets with highly technical
language,” a panelist pointed out. For instance, the copy for a type of
heat-shrink tubing states that “3M FP-301 is a heat shrinkable flexible
polyolefin tubing that offers an outstanding balance of electrical,
physical and chemical properties for a wide variety of industrial and
military applications. Rated for 275°F (135°C) continuous operation.
FP-301 tubing is typically used as a shrink-fit electrical insulation
over cable splices and terminations. It is also used for lightweight
wire harness covering, wire marking, wire bundling, component packaging
and fire resistant covering….” While a layperson wouldn't understand
much of this, Tessco's customers evidently do: The site boasts a high
conversion rate that impressed the judging panel.
Onsite
search provides relevant results and breaks them into categories. And
with searches for popular categories, Tessco breaks down the results
into subcategories, which is helpful, a judge said. Also, “the compare
feature is nice,” said another.
Why it didn't win a Gold Award
“Tessco
is assuming that their customers know exactly what they want and don't
need any help deciding,” said one judge. “There is no merchandising on
the site,” pointed out another. “The home page and category pages
expose categories and don't merchandise products, and product pages
hide categories and don't merchandise products. There are no
cross-sells or upsells.”
And
the ordering process is “incredibly confusing,” said a judge. “To add
to their cart, customers need to click on an add button that triggers a
JavaScript pop-up alert indicating that ‘the following SKU has been
added to the worksheet.’” To then begin checkout, customers need to
click on the “View worksheet” link. “The worksheet page is really the
shopping cart, and the ‘confirm price’ link is analogous to ‘process to
checkout,’” a judge said. — MD
Want to use this article? Click here for options!
© 2012 Penton Media Inc.
Acceptable Use Policy blog comments powered by Disqus












